GN Law - Our People News and TV

Is there a need for more certainty regarding nuptial agreements?

Our People - GN
Simona Obadia
9 July, 2015

In a recent case in the Royal Courts of Justice, Judge Nicholas Cusworth heard a man claiming he was earning ten times more than he in fact was.

A film-maker exaggerated his earnings to reassure his wealthy wife-to-be that he was not marrying her for her wealth. The man, who ran a small production company, had told how his income was £80,000 a year, when the real figure was a mere £8,000 the year before they tied the knot. The largest income he had ever produced was £32,000 a year.

His wife on the other hand, had inherited assets approaching £30 million, which included a share in a stately home.

While giving his oral evidence, the man said that the £200,000 figure represented the size of the budget of the films on which he was then working. The Judge ruled that this could never have been thought by him to have been an income figure and therefore the man in question knew that his income figures were untrue.

Despite the couple signing an agreement in 2002 promising not to make financial claims against one another in the event of a divorce, they racked up legal bills of nearly £1.8 million and argued at a hearing of more than three days.

The Judge concluded that the man should get £1.7 million for a home and the woman should pay him a lump sum of £215,000.

In this case, the nuptial agreement did not provide any certainty or clarity to parties in divorce proceedings. She entered into the marriage relying on the agreement that her then-husband would not make any financial claim against her. Nevertheless, she has been ordered to pay the man a lump sum and a large figure for a home.

The Judge’s ruling in this case may be a concern to some, given that it departs from the parties’ agreement in favour of the man; who presented as being untrustworthy. Furthermore, what was supposed to be a binding agreement between the parties, turned out to be a worthless exercise.

Related Articles

Two commonly used tools for couples to set out their rights, responsibilities, and financial plans are Cohabitation Agreements and Prenuptial Agreements. But how do they differ?
Our People - Loretta Orsi-Barzanti
The prospect of getting a divorce can be overwhelming, especially when attempting to understand the divorce procedure, related costs and timescales.
Our People - Loretta Orsi-Barzanti
A pre-proceedings meeting, or legal gateway meeting, means that the Local Authority is concerned about the care of your children and is considering taking the matter to Court.
Our People - Jalpa Vadgama
Receiving a pre-proceedings letter from Social Services can be a concerning and pivotal moment for families. The PLO letter indicates that the Local Authority is troubled about the welfare of your children and is contemplating court involvement.
Our People - Jalpa Vadgama
The term "Divorce Day" has gained traction, labelling the first Monday in January as a peak in divorce applications. But does this title accurately capture the surge in New Year divorce filings or merely serve as a journalistic trope?
Our People - Kathleen Bennet
Looking at the latest trends in divorce rates which increased in recent published data. Also what are the changes in divorce rates on 10 and 25 year marriages?
Our People - Kathleen Bennet

Send a message

We will only use the information you enter in this form to contact you about your enquiry and will not share it with anyone else. Please read our Privacy Notice.

Please note that we are not accepting any new housing work at this time.