GN Law - Our People News and TV

Should people with a history of mental health problems be prevented from undertaking certain employment roles?

Our People - GN
Simona Obadia
21 April, 2015

Nick Clegg says that there should be no ‘blanket rules’ when it comes to former mental health patients obtaining employment. ‘We certainly don’t want to see people with mental health problems deliberately or otherwise shut out of work. That would be consigning a lot of people to a cycle of despair, which would be wholly unfair and wholly unjust’ adds the Deputy Prime Minister.

One in every four people in the UK experiences a mental health problem each year. Is it ‘fair and just’ to hinder those people from obtaining employment due to their mental health history? Clearly, it is not.

There are many explanations for high unemployment rates among people with a history of mental health issues. Ongoing symptoms of mental health problems can make it difficult to work as can the side effects of treatments. Former patients who have recovered from mental health problems are turned down from certain employment positions when they reveal they have received treatment historically. Is it ‘fair and just’ to presume that, because someone has previously suffered from a mental health illness, it is likely to reoccur and act as a burden in their workplace? Clearly, it is not.

Germanwings crash pilot, Andreas Lubitz, suffered from suicidal tendencies before deliberately causing the disaster, investigators say. Does this mean all pilots with a history of mental health problems should be prevented from flying? I agree with Nick Clegg; if everyone with a historical mental illness were prohibited from working, a large population would be financially affected and this could cause a catastrophe in society.

So, blanket bans are unfair and unjust and cannot be allowed to persist.

Related Articles

Transitioning back to life after hospitalisation can be challenging. Did you know you might be entitled to free s117 aftercare services that can help you manage your mental health and get back on track?
Our People - Melissa Dieter
Recently, the Supreme Court has given a judgment regarding ‘ordinary residence’ and the circumstances in which someone is discharged from detention in hospital.
Our People - GN
A new start in the Mental Health department at GN Law, including a 90-day training program for new Paralegals.
Our People - GN
If you have been detained in hospital, or ‘sectioned’ as it is also known, under the Mental Health Act 1983 you may have a 'Nearest Relative'. This article will explore what the Nearest Relative is, who they are and what powers they have in relation to your care and treatment.
Our People - GN
Anna Johnson considers the Supreme Court decision in Re JB regarding capacity to consent to sexual activity.
Our People - Anna Johnson
Lillian Efstathiou considers the law on when and how a young person can be deprived of their liberty under the Mental Capacity Act 2005.
Our People - Lilian Efstathiou

Send a message

We will only use the information you enter in this form to contact you about your enquiry and will not share it with anyone else. Please read our Privacy Notice.

Please note that we are not accepting any new housing work at this time.