GN Law - Our People News and TV

Refusal of legal aid...... a false economy?

Our People - GN
Melissa Law
23 October, 2014

In the recent case of A Local Authority v M & Ors [2014] EWCOP 33 the judge, Mr Justice Baker, provided a stern warning that that denying individuals legal aid in complex Court of Protection cases causes undesirable delays and is therefore a false economy.

The case concerned M, a young adult who suffers from autism and a learning disability. An application had been made by the local authority to the Court of Protection for orders to be made in relation to M’s residence and care. M’s parents, who were in dispute with the local authority, were unrepresented in the proceedings.

Mr Justice Baker took the view that M’s parents had received a fair hearing and were not at a disadvantage because they had been provided with considerable assistance throughout the proceedings from the other legal teams involved; however this had also caused significant unwanted delays in the proceedings, including a 20 day fact finding hearing at huge expense to the court and the other parties.

Legal aid is not automatic in the majority of Court of Protection cases and individuals who wish to be granted the benefit of legal aid must usually first satisfy a ‘means’ and ‘merits’ test. In most of these cases, those who are not able to satisfy the ‘means’ test by a small margin are also unable to afford to pay for legal representation.

In the case of A Local Authority v M & Ors M’s parents were fortunate to have been afforded assistance from the other solicitors involved in the case, but it is important to note that this cannot be guaranteed in every case and ultimately, any unnecessary delays in Court of Protection hearings will be at the detriment of the vulnerable person to whom the proceedings concern.

Related Articles

The Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards (DoLS), an integral part of the Mental Capacity Act 2005, are crucial provisions designed to protect individuals who lack the mental capacity to make specific decisions about their well-being.
Our People - Maria Nicholas
The Office of the Public Guardian (OPG) released legal guidance tailored to professional deputies and attorneys concerning the rules governing gift-giving. This article highlights some of the key issues outlined in that guidance.
Our People - Navin Bundhoo
Recently, the Supreme Court has given a judgment regarding ‘ordinary residence’ and the circumstances in which someone is discharged from detention in hospital.
Our People - GN
When circumstances leave individuals unable to handle their own financial affairs, there are legal mechanisms available to protect their financial stability, such as Deputyship and LPAs. 
Our People - Lilian Efstathiou
The Court of Protection in the UK has the power to grant injunctions. But what is an injunction, and how does it relate to the Court of Protection?
Our People - Olivia Allen
A Standard Authorisation is used to lawfully deprive someone of their liberty in order to care for them. Can you challenge this? Is legal aid available?
Our People - Olivia Allen

Send a message

We will only use the information you enter in this form to contact you about your enquiry and will not share it with anyone else. Please read our Privacy Notice.

Please note that we are not accepting any new housing work at this time.